10 Best Toothpastes for Cavities 2021

This site contains affiliate links to products. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links.

If there are small, black areas in and around your teeth that are sometimes painful, you might have cavities. Dental caries, or otherwise known as cavities, are small areas of teeth where acids from food and drink have damaged the structure of the tooth. When you leave food residue on your teeth for prolonged periods of time without brushing, you leave your teeth susceptible to decay, and later on, cavities.

In the early stages of cavity development, simply choosing the right toothpaste can prevent any further problems. What’s not quite as simple is finding the best toothpaste for cavities. Overwhelmed with your options? Let this buying guide lead you to the right purchase.

Top 10 Toothpastes for Cavities Chart

PictureNameActive IngredientPriceRating (1-5)
Active Ingredient
Rating (1-5)
1. Colgate Cavity Protection ToothpasteFluoride$4.7
2. CariFree CTx4 Gel 1100, Dentist RecommendedFluoride$$$4.7
3. Redmond Earthpaste - Natural Non-Flouride ToothpasteRedmond Clay$$$$4.5
4. Sensodyne Toothpaste for Sensitive Teeth and Cavity PreventionFluoride$$$$4.5
5. Sensodyne Pronamel Gentle Whitening ToothpasteFluoride$$$$4.5
6. 3M ESPE 12117 Clinpro Tooth CremeFluoride$$$4.4
7. Uncle Harry's Fluoride Free ToothpasteBentonite Clay$$4.3
8. Crest 3D White Anti-Cavity Teeth Whitening ToothpasteFluoride$$$$4.3
9. Spry Xylitol Toothpaste with FluorideFluoride$$4.3
10. Tom's of Maine Anticavity Baking Soda ToothpasteSodium monofluorophosphate$$4.2

How to Choose a Good Toothpaste for Cavities

Not all of the toothpaste you’ll find in stores will work best to keep cavities at bay. Some of these products have more cavity fighting properties than others. Find the best toothpaste for cavities by keeping these tips in mind.

  • Read the Ingredients. Some toothpaste, especially those from affordable small-time brands, don’t do much aside from freshening your breath. For many, that can be good enough, but for people with cavities, these types of toothpaste are about the same as any old breath mint. Reading the labels and understanding what the ingredients do will help you choose a product that will protect you from cavities.

Fluoride is the most common cavity fighting ingredient in toothpaste; however there are non-fluoride toothpastes that claim to produce the same benefits without this common ingredient. For organic products, tea tree oil is the most common cavity fighting ingredient.

  • Synthetic vs. Natural. There are some people who are avoidant of synthetic products because of the side effects they might cause. With toothpaste, these can include irritation and sensitivity in the oral cavity. However, because these products are developed in clinics and labs, they’re much more likely to produce the results and effects that you want out of them.

With natural products, results can vary. Some people might say that an organic toothpaste was highly effective at resolving cavities, and then some might say that it didn’t work at all. The only upside to using natural toothpastes is that they often produce very little side effects and adverse reactions if any at all.

  • Multi-Benefit Formulation. Toothpaste can be developed for a plethora of different purposes. The most common are cavity protection, fresh breath, whitening, and gum health.

Depending on the problems you might want to address regarding your teeth and oral cavity, you may want to purchase a product that targets more than just one issue. However, it pays to keep in mind that because these products have more ingredients than others do, their cavity protection properties might be somewhat dampened compared to those that are specifically formulated for cavities alone.

Top 3 Best Toothpaste for Cavities Reviews

1. Colgate Cavity Protection Toothpaste

Very few have achieved the popularity of Colgate when it comes to toothpaste. This long-standing and well-trusted brand has been around for decades and is considered the leading brand when it comes to oral health products. Considered the best toothpaste for cavities is the Colgate Cavity Protection Toothpaste which incorporates high concentrations of fluoride for healthy teeth that are free and protected from cavities.

The formulation itself is very straightforward and focuses mainly on cavity protection; however, it is also popular thanks to its fresh minty flavor and whitening properties that are much more effective compared to other brands on the market.

When it comes right down to prices, Colgate Cavity Protection Toothpaste takes the cake. This highly effective formulation doesn’t only get the job done, it also costs just a fraction of others’ prices. Plus, Colgate Cavity Protection Toothpaste is well-known as a safe brand that’s formulated for all types of people, so it’s the perfect product to have in your bathroom for your whole family to use.

2. CariFree CTx4 Gel 1100

Coming in at a close second for the best toothpaste for cavity protection is CariFree CTx4 Gel 1100. This product takes on the consistency of a thick gel instead of a paste and works to fight off cavities with the standard fluoride ingredient found in most other toothpastes on the market. What’s more, it also combines xylitol with its main active ingredient, making it a highly effective remedy for fast and safe cavity prevention and removal.

Another thing to enjoy about the product is that it’s non-abrasive; this means it will not react with residual food and impurities lodged between your teeth, so you can be sure that each use will be safe for overall oral health and won’t aggravate the cavities that might already exist.

The only issue that some users have with CariFree CTx4 Gel 1100 is that it can be on the pricier end of the spectrum. For its steep cost, buyers can purchase up to three tubes of a few other options on the list.

3. Redmond Earthpaste Natural Non-Flouride Toothpaste

If you’re looking for an organic, all-natural toothpaste that you can use to help fight off cavities, Redmond Earthpaste Natural Non-Flouride Toothpaste is the product for you. This formulation is fluoride-free and uses food grade Redmond clay to get rid of cavities instead. It works by neutralizing the acids left behind by food and thus preventing them from eating away the enamel and dentin of the teeth.

While it is effective for most users, there are some that complain about the freshening properties of Redmond Earthpaste Natural Non-Flouride Toothpaste. It’s not quite as minty or fresh as other options, so it may cause some unease after use especially for people who are particular about the freshness of their breath.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *